For the most physically demanding position in baseball, we want to give the opportunity to choose the perfect glove for any player willing to step in and squat behind the plate. Top of the line glove brands flood our warehouse with their best gloves to offer, and we could not be happier with the choices you have. 7 of the world's greatest glove brands have created catchers mitts for the hardest position in the game. Our wide variety of catchers mitts can be found right here on our site as well as our physical store. Any questions about these amazing gloves can be answered by us 7 days a week!

Bases Loaded has one of the largest selections of Baseball Catcher’s Mitts in the entire country! There is no catcher’s mitt we carry that we would not use in a game. At Bases Loaded, we carry some of the best brands of catcher’s mitts in the game. We carry All-Star, Easton, Marucci, Mizuno, Nokona, Rawlings, and Wilson. Each brand has their own unique differences and qualities that set themselves apart from each other. But before we get to each brand, we need to dive in to the different sizes of catcher’s mitts. Because when it comes to catcher’s mitts, size does matter!

Catcher’s mitts will range from 31-35”. Your youth catcher’s mitts will be anywhere from a 31-32”, and adult mitts being 32-35”. The main difference between the youth and adult catcher’s mitts will be the hand size and fit of the finger stalls. For the adult catcher’s mitts, each size will have certain attributes. A 32- 32.5” catcher’s mitt will be for catchers who want a more nimble glove. This size will help catchers get the ball out of their glove quicker on transfers. In turn, this will help cut down on their pop time to second base. A 34” catcher’s mitt will be more for the catcher who is super concerned with framing and receiving. The 34” mitt will have a bigger surface area for the ball to be gobbled up. This will in turn help a catcher’s framing and receiving abilities. If you’re a catcher who catches a lot of pitchers who throw a lot of off-speed with good movement, you might want to consider a 34” catcher’s glove.  But, because the glove and pocket are much bigger, the ball has a tendency to be deeper into the glove which can prolong the transfer. As catchers, we know that even a split second can be the difference between a base runner being safe and out. So, it’s definitely a lot of give and take between a 32.5” mitt and a 34” mitt. But, you can get a glove that is right in between with a 33” catcher’s mitt. A 33” mitt seems to be one of the more popular sizes. And lastly, we carry a 35” catcher’s mitt that is specifically made for catching knuckleball or off-speed dominant pitchers. This 35” mitt will give you the ability get a glove on pitches that have insane movement. A lot of professional catchers have a 35” mitt in their bag for those certain type of pitchers.

All-Star specializes in catcher’s gear and catcher’s mitts. It only makes sense that they are one of the most popular catcher’s gloves in every level of baseball. All-Star has several models that include their Pro Comp Series, Pro Advanced Series, and their infamous Pro Elite Series. The Pro Comp Series will come in a 31.5” youth model, and a 33.5” adult model. The Pro Comp will have a softer tanned cowhide leather and rawhide lace that will break in fairly quickly and be perfect for someone who is newer to catching. The Pro Advanced Series comes in a 33.5” size and is a perfect mitt for an adult catcher who doesn’t want to break the bank, but still wants a top quality product. The Pro Advanced features Japanese tanned steer hide leather and heavy duty rawhide lace that will hold up to the rigorous task of being a catcher. One of the most popular catcher’s mitt ever is the All-Star Pro Elite. This catcher’s  mitt has literally not changed in 15 years. Why you ask? Quite frankly, it doesn’t need to change! The Pro Elite comes in a 33.5”, 35”, and a 31.5” Junior model. The Pro Elite is made of Japanese Tanned Steer-Hide Leather and Professional Grade leather lace. It literally doesn’t get any better than the All-Star Pro Elite. That’s why the Pro Elite has been one of the most used catcher’s mitts in baseball year after year.

Though fairly new to world of baseball gloves in general, Marucci has managed to put out some of the best quality gloves on the market. Marucci has several catcher’s mitt models that include  the Oxbow Series, RS225 Series, Ascension Series, Cypress Series, and their Capitol Series. Marucci’s RS225 Youth Series catcher’s mitt measures in at 31.5”, and features a soft Tumble cowhide leather shell. The RS225 also has scaled down finger stalls that make this a perfect youth catcher’s mitt. Marucci’s Ascension Series is also a youth mitt that has a lightweight design and is made of tight-grain steerhide that is durable and makes for easy break-in for younger athletes. The Oxbow Series catcher’s mitt is Marucci’s most versatile series. The full-grain cowhide leather being flexible and easy to break in makes this a perfect glove for beginners all the way to a high school player. The Marucci Cypress  Series catcher’s mitt is a 33.5” that is constructed of top-of-the-line Premium Japanese-Tanned steerhide leather and an extra-smooth cowhide lining. This mitt is perfect for any elite catcher looking for catcher’s mitt that will last season after season. Marucci’s nicest catcher’s mitt will be their Capitol series. The Capitol Series is made of Premium Japanese-Tanned Kip Leather, which is one of the most durable leathers in the world. This will help keep the shape of this mitt year after year. Marucci might be new at the glove game, but don’t let that fool you. Marucci makes one of the nicest catcher’s mitt you can get your hands on.

It’s safe to say that Rawlings has never made a bad ball glove. And that still holds true when it comes to Rawlings catcher’s mitts. Rawlings offers more models of catcher’s mitts than any other company. Rawlings’ catcher’s mitt models are the Renegade, Player Preferred, Sandlot, R9, Encore, Heart of the Hide, and Pro Preferred. Each model has its own differences, from leather quality to size and shape. The Rawlings Renegade Series comes in a youth 31.5” and an adult 32.5” mitt. What’s nice about the Renegade is that the leather is already so soft that Rawlings claims the glove is 80% broken-in right off of the shelf. The Rawlings Player Preferred series is constructed of a softer, full-grain leather shell that is flexible enough to make the break-in process a breeze. The 33” size of the Player Preferred catcher’s mitt makes it versatile for any age of athlete. The next Catcher’s mitt from Rawlings is the Sandlot Series that measures in at 33”.  This adult catcher’s mitt has an oiled, old-fashioned looking leather shell and all-leather laces that make this glove easy to use and durable. This glove has a vintage look and feel suitable for any level of athlete. One of the most widely popular models is the Rawlings R9 catcher’s mitt series. The R9 Series comes in a 32” youth model and a 32.5” adult model. The R9 catcher’s mitts are the best mitts on the market at that price point. They not only have that traditional Rawlings touch, but also feature a soft, durable leather shell designed to be game-ready. Rawlings most popular series are the Heart of the Hide and the Pro Preferred catcher’s mitts. These are the same models and series you’ll see college and professional players using. Not only do they have professional quality leather, but also have Rawlings’ finest craftsmanship and engineering.

Wilson is one of the most recognizable gloves in baseball today. Wilson did not just appear into the hands of many professional baseball players. The people at Wilson have spent countless hours refining the craft of making high quality baseball gloves. Lets dive into the Wilson catcher’s glove lineup shall we? Wilson makes five different models of catcher’s mitts. The first is their youth catcher’s mitt called the A500. This mitt is soft and flexible due to the top grain leather that makes this an ideal mitt for any young, aspiring catcher. Next on the list is the Wilson A900 catcher’s mitt. This glove features an all-leather construction that literally requires almost zero break-in. The old-school look of this A900 coupled with the 34” design makes this a glove you could buy on Friday, and use on Saturday! The next catcher’s mitt on the Wilson lineup is the A1000. This 33” A1000 model features a Velcro wrist strap that ensures a secure fit inning after inning. This catcher’s mitt will feel similar to an A2000, but will break in much quicker due to the thinner Pro Stock Leather. The most popular Wilson model is the A2000, a timeless classic. The Wilson A2000 catcher’s mitt comes in a 33”, 33.5”, and a 34”. You also have the option of getting a SuperSkin model that speeds up break-in and reduces the weight of the glove by fifty percent. And last but not least, the granddaddy of them all, the Wilson A2K catcher’s model. The A2K model comes in a popular 33.5” size and features the top five percent of Wilson’s Pro Stock Select leather. In other words, it is the nicest leather Wilson can get their hands on.